A former United Nations spokesman, replying to a five-day-old post about Holocaust Remembrance Day, demanded a Holocaust museum respond to a ten-year-old Israeli comment.
Chris Gunness was the spokesman for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA).
Recent Stories in Issues
On Monday, Gunness found a Twitter post from Yad Vashem, a museum and center for Holocaust research. The post commemorated Holocaust Remembrance Day, observed last Thursday.
The museum's full post, written on Holocaust Remembrance Day, read:
Each year, six Holocaust survivors are chosen to light torches in memory of the six million Jews who were murdered during the #Holocaust. Watch the stories of all 6 torch-lighters chosen for the 2019 Holocaust Remembrance Day State Opening Ceremony here
Gunness took the opportunity to demand comment on a former Israeli official's comment about a "shoah" against the Palestinians.
What is Yad Vashem's response to the threat by Matan Vilnai, former Israeli Deputy Defense Minister, to inflict a shoah or holocaust on Gaza & the Palestinians?https://t.co/62CenGWyIP
— Chris Gunness (@ChrisGunness) May 6, 2019
Gunness linked to a 2008 story from the Guardian about Israel and a Palestinian "holocaust."
In April 2008, following a barrage of Hamas-fired rockets from the Gaza Strip, former Israeli Deputy Defense Minister Matan Vilnai warned of a shoah (lit. "catastrophe, holocaust") in response.
"The more Qassam [Hamas rocket] fire intensifies and the rockets reach a longer range, they will bring upon themselves a bigger shoah because we will use all our might to defend ourselves," he said on army radio.
The term "shoah" is biblical. It means "catastrophe," with connotations of fire. It is the term Israelis use to refer to the Holocaust. Its Ancient Greek translation, "holokaustos," is used in English. The word "Holocaust" became the term for the Nazi-led genocide of Jews and other European populations in World War II.
Following global coverage of Vilnai's remarks, a spokesperson clarified he meant to use the word in its general sense.
"The minister used the Hebrew term ‘shoah' which means ‘catastrophe' and in this context does not refer to the ‘the Shoah' – the Holocaust," a representative said.
Palestinian leadership frequently denies the occurrence of the Holocaust. Palestinian officials and their foreign defenders frequently describe Israeli policy as Nazi-esque and the current situation as a Holocaust.
A year after the comment in question, for example, the Associated Press reported the following:
A Hamas spiritual leader on Monday called teaching Palestinian children about the Nazi murder of 6 million Jews a "war crime," rejecting a suggestion that the U.N. might include the Holocaust in Gaza's school curriculum.
Many Palestinians are reluctant to acknowledge Jewish suffering, fearing it might diminish their own. Attitudes toward the Holocaust range from outright denial to challenging its scope.
Vilnai offered his comment, albeit artlessly, in that context.
On Monday, Gunness wrote a separate tweet accusing Israeli officials of "exploitation of the holocaust [sic] and Nazi-esque behavoir [sic]."
I will continue to call out the exploitation of the holocaust and Nazi-esque behavoir and rhetoric even from Israeli Ministers. So should you if you really care about honest reporting. https://t.co/pF1FuRacSX
— Chris Gunness (@ChrisGunness) May 7, 2019
The account Gunness used for his tweets is listed as his official Twitter page the U.N.'s website.
A 2015 U.N. report found "it was highly likely that a Palestinian armed group might have used [UNRWA school] premises to hide weapons."
In 2017, Israel discovered Hamas-built tunnels running underneath an UNRWA-run school. Hamas uses the tunnels to rapidly move soldiers, hostages, and weapons out of reach of Israeli forces.
Gunness has previously addressed UNRWA members making inappropriate comments on social media.
In February 2017, Gunness released a statement addressing a "number of allegations … made against alleged UNRWA staff members which we are looking into as part of our ongoing commitment to maintaining the Agency’s neutrality."
He promised the agency would "launch specific neutrality and social media training for senior managers across all five UNRWA fields of operations and headquarters."
His comments followed a story in Bild, a German news site, about UNRWA-paid staff using Facebook to spread anti-semitism. The story reported that "teachers are spreading anti-Semitic videos and caricatures, as well as open calls for violence against Jews, with students commenting" (emphasis in original).
Gunness is himself a frequent source for fringe anti-Israel news sites.
As of press time, Gunness had offered no apology for his comment or commemoration of Holocaust Remembrance Day.