Rocky Road

REVIEW: 'Going the Distance: Stallone, Philly, and the Story of Rocky' by Mike Sielski

(Macmillan Publishers)
image/svg+xml

"It was just a fairy story, but it had legs of cement," was Burt Young's felicitous assessment of Rocky, for which Young received an Oscar nomination as the title character's friend Paulie. It "wasn't a fighting story," he continued. "It was a love story about someone standing up—not even winning, just standing up."

Mike Sielski's book Going the Distance: Stallone, Philly, and the Story of Rocky is a fast read that contains scores of such pleasing observations and amusing details. It arrives concurrently with two other big projects on the making of Rocky upon its 50th anniversary this month: Its star and writer Sylvester Stallone has just published his memoir The Steps while theaters are rolling out the utterly charming drama I Play Rocky. Rocky wasn't just a massive cinematic success, it forged a template for underdog sports movies: The Karate Kid, Hoosiers, Rudy, even Dodgeball.

"It was so heartfelt and so without guile," remembers Garrett Brown, who used his then-new Steadicam invention on Rocky's indelible run up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art. "It wasn't elegant. It wasn't slick. It wasn't contrived. It wasn't sophisticated. It just felt inevitable from the first line." Stallone, who dreamed up the character and fought to star in the movie, perspicaciously said at the time of its release, "The cynical antiheroes of our recent films were the result of Vietnam and the Democratic convention, of everyone being down on everything. … Watergate was the end of it. The boil was lanced. We're beginning to rebuild."

Sielski has assembled a trove of interesting trivia via diligent research and doggedly obtained interviews with principal figures (many of whom are still alive, notably composer Bill Conti, Brown, producer Irwin Winkler, former United Artists production chief Mike Medavoy, and even Chuck "the Bayonne Bleeder" Wepner, whose no-hope 1975 fight against Muhammad Ali inspired Stallone's screenplay). Stallone refused interviews but answered a few questions via email.

Again and again, the underdog elements of the story are mirrored in its production; the movie shot for five days in Philadelphia with guerrilla urgency, without permits, using non-union crews from New York. "We hid from everybody," recalls Winkler. The skating-rink scene was supposed to include hundreds of extras, but the production couldn't afford them, resulting in the enchantingly empty space hosting Rocky and Adrian's romantic skating date.

When Conti, whose score elevated the film from excellence to glory, needed singers to perform on "Gonna Fly Now," he called his wife and asked her to find a couple of other singers in her office. "They were people who came over on their lunch break," he told the author. (Conti claims the final shots of the movie were his idea; director John G. Avildsen's original ending, which flopped with test audiences, was to have Rocky and Adrian quietly exit the arena, forgotten by the crowd. Conti said he had a composition to back an emotional, climactic reunion after Rocky's girlfriend Adrian fought her way to the ring.)

Sielski is a clunky writer, and the book has so much filler (do we really need to hear what Philadelphia pop stars Hall & Oates were up to at the time?) that everything of interest in it probably could have fit in 180 pages. (It runs a little over 250 plus end matter.) Still, there is a lot of eye-opening pushback against Stallone's accounts, which invariably flattered him. For instance, in retelling the tale over the years he kept inflating the amount of money he was supposedly offered to sell the screenplay and forsake his wish to star in the project; $75,000 became $100,000 became $360,000.

At the very end Sielski delicately broaches a matter that casts a cloud over the whole cheerful underdog fable: Stallone quickly became an arrogant jerk. This is understood in Hollywood and has been for many years, which is why he will never win an Oscar.

Whatever humility he possessed at the time Rocky was made was burned away by the klieg lights. He apparently believed he would have won Best Actor at the Academy Awards had Peter Finch, the star of Network, not died just weeks before the vote in January 1977. When Finch's name was called at the ceremony, Sielski notes, Stallone blinked in disbelief and did not applaud. Stallone also failed to win Best Original Screenplay, which also went to Network; he had been only the third person (after Charles Chaplin and Orson Welles!) to be nominated in both categories at the same time. Thirty-nine years would go by before he got another Oscar nomination, for playing Rocky yet again in Creed, but Mark Rylance won for the Steven Spielberg drama Bridge of Spies.

Stallone also continues to cultivate a long-running feud with Winkler, who is 95. He has serially denigrated other important talents; when a journalist asked whether he would supply reminiscences on Avildsen for an HBO series called The Great Directors, Stallone said, "Avildsen is not a great director! I will talk to you about Rocky but do not ask me any questions about Avildsen." In a December 2024 email to Sielski, Stallone was still outraged that two colleagues won the Oscar for best film editing: "Scott Conrad? Really? Richard Halsey? I had to re-edit everything they did. And they got the Oscar!!" Conrad evenly told Sielski, "That assertion is ridiculous," adding that he had seen Stallone in the editing suite exactly once. "I'm sorry to hear that he is still so bitter. … It is my belief that his entire career has been an attempt to win an Oscar, not that that is completely unusual."

This goes back a long time. Bob Lardine, entertainment reporter for the Daily News of New York, wrote in 1978—barely a year after Rocky's Oscar triumphs—"People swear he bears no resemblance to the Sly Stallone of two years ago. Something happened to him when Rocky rocketed him to international fame and millionaire status. They claim he's now a surly, antisocial, arrogant egomaniac." A fellow actor from the cast of Rocky said, "He's become such a bastard that even his dog, Butkus, turned on him and bit him."

Remember that metafictional moment in Rocky III when Stallone, as Rocky, humbly confronts the heft of his own legend as he regards the giant statue of Rocky at the Philadelphia Museum of Art? It was Stallone himself who commissioned and paid for the mighty monument to Stallone and asked for it to be placed there—essentially as a prop for his movie. The figure has since been moved several times amid hot debate about whether an item of what is essentially Hollywood kitsch should be associated with fine art. Last month it was reinstalled at the top of the steps. Wags note that it would be much more of a boon to the city if it were placed inside the museum, which could sell tickets to see it.

If any film deserves a vigorous burst of anniversary hype, though, it's the soiled symphony that is Rocky, and Going the Distance both celebrates how a wonderful movie came to be and supplies plenty of fodder for the many detractors Stallone has earned over the years. Yes, it's aimed squarely at fans, but if you're not a fan, there's something wrong with you.

Going the Distance: Stallone, Philly, and the Story of Rocky
by Mike Sielski
St. Martin's Press, 304 pp., $30

Kyle Smith is a columnist and film critic at the Wall Street Journal.

Published under: Book reviews , Film , Movies

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT