Global Journalists’ Group Quietly Cuts 40 Terrorists’ Names From Its ‘Slain Gaza Journalists’ List, Contradicting Embattled Committee to Protect Journalists

The International Federation of Journalists has a similar mess on its hands to the CPJ, but its definition of a ‘journalist’ screens out more Palestinian militants

(International Federation of Journalists)
image/svg+xml

The International Federation of Journalists quietly excised 40 names from its widely cited list of "journalists" killed in Gaza, an attempted clean-up likely meant to ward off further criticism after the Washington Free Beacon first documented the list’s inclusion of multiple battle-hardened terrorists.

Seven of the names struck off the Brussels-based group’s list remain on a dueling list maintained by the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists, which after its own review has doubled down on classifying many Palestinian militants who masqueraded as newsmen as "slain journalists." More than half the names on CPJ’s now revised list of supposed journalists slain in Gaza "have connections to terrorist groups," the Free Beacon first reported last month.

The IFJ, which touts itself as the world’s largest advocacy group for reporters, has been under fire for including as "slain journalists" confirmed terrorists who were active on the battlefield. The situation mirrors that of the CPJ, which is facing similar scrutiny for its list of "slain journalists" in Gaza and recently removed some names after months of infighting.

The clash between the two dueling lists—with the CPJ list continuing to include the names of seven "journalists" removed from the IFJ list—highlights how both groups are struggling to make the case—without credible evidence—that Israel targets Palestinian journalists. The IFJ, for its part, has tried to dodge more scrutiny by only vaguely acknowledging that it’s removed at least 40 names from its list since early October. A small disclaimer online that says the IFJ "is working hard to keep this list up-to-date and accurate."

The IFJ says that it is still working "closely" to verify information with its affiliate, the Palestinian Journalists' Syndicate, a little-known Palestinian journalist group that the Free Beacon first reported in September is run by a West Bank activist who regularly calls for bloodshed and touts terrorists as "heroes."

Two media watchdog groups highly critical of the "slain journalist in Gaza" lists—the Israel-based Honest Reporting and the Boston-based Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis (CAMERA)—separately claimed, based on parallel investigations, that sometime between October 3 and October 8, the IFJ quietly expunged 37 names, followed by 3 more in early November. Both audits were shared exclusively with the Free Beacon and reveal that most of the deleted names were Palestinian combatants for Hamas or other terrorist groups who were posing as reporters.

In several cases, the IFJ quietly deleted entries from its list, but the individuals remain listed in CPJ’s database. This could be due to the way in which CPJ defines a journalist: After weeks of infighting, the group’s board voted 17-1 earlier this year to affirm that "organizations affiliated with militant groups" meet the criteria of a legitimate journalistic outlet "provided they are not engaging in combat or inciting violence in a manner likely to have imminent effect."

The IFJ’s definition, by contrast, is more traditional: "A journalist is one who devotes the greater part of his/her working time to the profession of journalism and who derives from it most of his/her income being employed or working as a freelance."

In the case of Jamal Al-Faqaawi—who worked for a PIJ-aligned outlet while also serving as a branch commander in the terror group’s support and supply unit—the IFJ removed his name from its list, though he remains on CPJ’s database, HonestReporting found.

Also removed from the IFJ list but remaining on the CPJ list is Ibrahim Sheikh Ali—who worked for the PIJ-affiliated Al-Quds Al-Youm while serving as a platoon commander in its Central Operations Unit. He was reclassified by CPJ on September 24 from a "media worker" to a "journalist." The IDF says he was an "Islamic Jihad operations and combat propaganda operative," and his name no longer appears on IFJ’s list of slain reporters.

Hamas has long disguised its fighters as journalists, giving them large "PRESS" insignias or embedding them with video news teams, where the fighters masquerade as shooters or sound techs. The practice is similar to how Hamas operates beneath hospitals, schools, and mosques.

At least 32 of the individuals removed by the IFJ from its "slain journalists" list in October were also deleted from CPJ’s own contested database following a late September audit largely sparked by the Free Beacon’s coverage.

"The narrative that the IDF deliberately targeted Gazan journalists during the October 7 War continues to collapse, as IFJ has quietly purged dozens of names from its lists of slain media workers not long after CPJ removed almost two dozen as well," HonestReporting said in a statement. IFJ, the watchdog group noted, "even removed terrorists that CPJ still has listed as journalists."

"Both these organizations served as trusted sources by news outlets, and were cited in hundreds of articles," HonestReporting said. "Yet with the admission that these databases were wrong, they have not only demonstrated that the narrative was built on false information, but that these organizations have no credibility."

HonestReporting determined that the IFJ has been cited at least 109 times in news articles since Hamas’s Oct. 7, 2023, terror attack ignited the war in Gaza and spurred accusations that Israel is intentionally targeting journalists. CPJ, meanwhile, has cited the IFJ 14 times in its own work on the subject, showing how both organizations bolster one another to peddle a circular narrative that the "Israeli army has deliberately targeted journalists," as the IFJ frames it online.

The CPJ, whose board is brimming with editors and writers who are overtly hostile to Israel, goes further, saying that "Israel is engaging in the deadliest and most deliberate effort to kill and silence journalists that CPJ has ever documented."

Until October 3 of this year, the IFJ’s list included 240 supposed journalists and media workers who had been killed in Gaza. That number fell to 203 after October 8, and by November 4, three more names were nixed and a replacement article was published on the organization's website touting this new number. There is no disclosure from IFJ acknowledging the deletions, explaining its methodology, or otherwise noting what shifted in the span of a few days. The organization did not respond to a Free Beacon request for comment on the matter.

Between July and August of this year, as the Free Beacon first reported, IFJ quietly removed nine names from its list without any acknowledgment, bringing the full total of deletions this year to 49. Among those individuals purged in early October, 34 were found to be Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad members who were mourned by their families and friends online as "Jihad fighters," according to CAMERA’s audit.

Tamar Sternthal, the director of CAMERA’s Israel office, said, "It is deeply concerning" that the IFJ purged its list "without issuing a prominent correction notice."

"The IFJ’s previous figures were widely cited in international reporting, heavily shaping global public discourse surrounding the Gaza war," Sternthal said. "This stealth edit is clear evidence that the IFJ is attempting to evade public accountability for its severe failures of scrutiny. An organization representing journalists must be held to the highest standards of transparency."

In many cases, the IFJ deleted names in October after CPJ had done so very publicly just a month prior.

Mohammad Jarghoun—who was hailed by Hamas as a "martyred Jihad fighter" and a member of its al-Qassam Battalions—was purged from IFJ’s list shortly after CPJ did the same upon determining he "engaged in combat" and was not a reporter, according to CAMERA’s research.

Similar circumstances surround IFJ’s deletion of Yasser Abu Namous, who was mourned online by his widow and sister as a "martyred Jihad fighter" and a member of Hamas’s al-Qassam Battalions. His name was removed from the CPJ’s list upon a determination that he engaged in combat.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT