Ilhan Omar and Keith Ellison’s Claim That Attack on Uber Driver Was Anti-Somali ‘Hate Crime’ Collapses After DA Declines To Bring Hate Charges Against Indian Suspect

Even the far-left DA overseeing the case said there was insufficient evidence to charge the suspect with a hate crime

Ilhan Omar (Kent Nishimura/Getty Images)
image/svg+xml

Both Minnesota congresswoman Ilhan Omar (D.) and state attorney general Keith Ellison (D.) quickly denounced a brutal attack on a Somali Uber driver over the weekend in the Minneapolis suburbs as an anti-Somali hate crime. The claim fell apart after prosecutors charged an Indian-American assailant on Tuesday for the attack and said there is insufficient evidence to charge him with a hate crime.

Hennepin county attorney Mary Moriarty (D.) on Tuesday announced second-degree attempted murder and carjacking charges against Samit Patel in the alleged attack early Saturday on 51-year-old Uber driver Mohamed Yusuf. Patel allegedly choked Yusuf with a belt while riding in his Uber, threw him out of the car, ran him over, and left him for dead on the side of the road.

The case drew national attention after Omar, Ellison, and Muslim activist groups quickly portrayed the attack as an anti-Somali and anti-Muslim hate crime.

"This horrific act of racial violence is unacceptable. No one should live in fear because of who they are," said Omar, a Somali-American immigrant who is under federal investigation for immigration fraud amid accusations that she married her brother and lied about her age. "The relentless dehumanization of the Somali community has real consequences."

"My heart breaks for Mohamed, his loved ones, and our Somali and Muslim communities apparently targeted by this assault," said Ellison, who posted a video from a Somali-American news outlet that includes a woman who wears a hijab and face mask and calls the attack a "pure hate crime."

The basis for that claim came from Yusuf’s family. Yusuf’s brother, who was on the phone with him, said he overheard a passenger tell Yusuf he, the passenger, did not like his name Mohamed. The brother later heard Yusuf scream out that he was being choked.

But Patel’s arrest and additional details undercut left-wing Democrats’ claims about a hate crime.

Even Moriarty, one of a crop of left-wing prosecutors backed by liberal billionaire George Soros, said evidence was "insufficient" to bring hate crime charges in the attack. Moriarty provided details of Patel’s arrest report, including that Patel's parents called 911 after he came home drunk and belligerent.

"He was incoherent and difficult to understand. He began by asking officers to arrest him," the report says.

Moriarty said at a press conference Patel seemed to be having a "mental health" episode. While she said there was insufficient evidence to charge a hate crime, she condemned President Donald Trump and others for stoking what she said was anti-Somali hatred.

"I completely understand the reaction to this horrific assault and the expectation for this case to be reviewed for bias motivation," said Moriarty, who stoked controversy in Minneapolis last year by ordering prosecutors to take suspects’ "racial identity" into account when negotiating plea deals.

The Trump administration has ramped up scrutiny of Minnesota’s sizable Somali community amid investigations into widespread fraud at Somali-led nonprofits in the area. Dozens of Somali Americans have been indicted as part of the $250 million Feeding Our Future scam, in which nonprofit groups defrauded a government program designed to provide lunches to school kids during the coronavirus pandemic.

The administration has also investigated Omar for potential immigration fraud. According to reports, investigators are looking into whether Omar lied about her age on visa applications and whether she married her brother as part of a green card scam. The Biden administration investigated Omar over her contacts with an unnamed foreign government and her campaign spending.

Little is known about Patel, the 25-year-old suspect in the attack on Yusuf. He has several traffic citations on his criminal record and an alcohol-related offense. His family members did not respond to a request for comment.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT